House vacation rentals in Sugarloaf Key

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Sugarloaf Key

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A spacious outdoor dining area features a glass-top table with several red chairs, set against a vibrant backdrop of greenery and water. The view of the calm sea and fluffy clouds can be seen in the distance, enhancing the tranquil setting.

Home in Cudjoe Key

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Yellow Home Free Pontoon Rental! See details

If you book your stay for the days shown below March 30th - April 15th, 2025 April 23rd - May 3rd, 2025 May 17th - May 31st, 2025 June 6th - June 13th, 2025 Receive a free 2 day boat rental for a week reservation, 1 day for a 3 days or more reservation. Please reach out before booking for boat availability. Beautiful 3 bedroom 2 bath home nestled off of US 1. Kayaks included with the rental. Private heated pool and deck with a view of the Atlantic Ocean. Boat dockage available with parking.

Top guest favorite

A serene view of a canal populated by several pelicans floating on the water's surface. Palm trees line the shore, and colorful houses are visible in the background. A boat is docked nearby, enhancing the peaceful coastal scene.

Home in Key Colony Beach

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Waterfront House with 37 ft Dock & Cabana Club

Right in the middle of the action between Miami and Key West. This 2/2 house has been nicely renovated and furnished with new stainless kitchen appliances and a gorgeous granite countertop. Comfortable outside/inside living space perfect for a getaway in paradise. Walk out to the porch and backyard, and you will be engulfed by the beauty of the sunset views while lying on the cozy hammock. It features lots of outdoor entertaining: fishing, paddling, BBQ or just plain hanging out in the shade.

Superhost

A modern living area features a spacious white sectional sofa adorned with blue and green decorative pillows. A wooden dining table with white chairs is positioned nearby. Above, a stylish fan circulates air while artwork in calming hues decorates the walls, complementing the light wood flooring.

Home in Key Largo

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

New Oceanside Casa Azul! Voted #1! Golf Cart-Beach

No hidden fees! Casa Azul blends luxury and laid-back island vibes in the heart of Key Largo. With Superhost status and hundreds of 5-star reviews, a perfect escape. Voted the #1 Vacation Rental in Key Largo, it’s ideal for families, couples, and groups alike. Enjoy a free golf cart, fast Wi-Fi, 2 pools, private beach, saltwater lagoon, kayaks, tennis and pickleball courts with gear, marina access, boat ramp, trailer parking, and optional slip rentals. Salt Life meets luxury - this is the one.

Guest favorite

The exterior of the house features a vibrant yellow façade with blue accents. A wooden staircase leads to a screened-in porch, while shaded areas beneath the house are furnished with comfortable seating. Lush greenery and palm trees enhance the coastal atmosphere.

Home in Marathon

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Oceanview Oasis! Screened Porch & Outdoor Theater

Getaway to Paradise in Sunny Marathon! Furnished in comfort and opulence, this private, well-appointed 2 bed 2 bath house boasts: +5-Star OCEANVIEWS +Cozy Screened-in Porch +Outdoor Theater +Jumbo Nest Chairs over lush beach sand +Shade and Sun Loungers +Full Kitchen +Electric Smoker Grill Ready for Adventure? 5 Minutes from the Keys' best public sandy beaches (Sombrero and Bahai Honda State Park), Theater of the Sea, Marathon Aquarium, Dolphin Research Ctr, Turtle Hosp'l and 7-Mile Bridge!

Guest favorite

A modern two-story home features a clean white exterior with navy blue accents. A set of black stairs leads to a covered balcony adorned with potted plants. Large windows allow natural light to enter, while a gravel driveway provides ample space in front.

Home in Marathon

5 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

Waterfront Escape -VACA-23-408

Come stay at this brand new home construction on a deep and wide canal leading to the ocean with pool and exotic decor. 75 foot dock with water and electric. Top of the line appliances with a fully stocked kitchen. Spa style showers with high end decor. Luxury at its best. Heated pool with sundeck and lots of seating around the edges. (Pool heater is an additional $100 per stay). Ground level cooking and dining for those beautiful days after boating or while laying around in the pool.

Guest favorite

A covered deck features wooden furniture, including a table and chairs. The view overlooks a wide waterway with lush greenery and small boats. A bright blue sky with soft clouds provides a scenic backdrop.

Home in Marathon

5 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews

Amazing Bayfront New House with Dock and Pool!

NEW TO MARKET AND AVAILABLE FOR LOBSTER MINI SEASON!!! This new construction has everything. This concrete house is waterfront with great views of Bonefish Bay. The 70 foot dock is built in 10-12 foot water. It is frequented by manatee, dolphin, and numerous mangrove snapper. The large heated pool is surrounded by Turkish marble pavers that are cool to your feet. House has double master suites with en suite bathrooms and every necessity to make our home feel like yours.

Guest favorite

A renovated house is set on a corner lot, surrounded by palm trees and coral stone landscaping. The exterior features light yellow walls and white accents. A gravel driveway offers ample parking space, complementing the tranquil tropical environment.

Home in Marathon

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Marathon Star - home with hot tub

Completely renovated 3 bedroom house in Marathon. Conveniently located near the Florida Keys Aquarium Encounters and the Marathon Lady. Enjoy a private hot tub and outdoor grill after a long day of Florida sunshine! Our home is not on the water but there is plenty of parking space for your boat trailer if needed. We hope our wonderful space becomes a great home away from home. ***Please see below for more information regarding hurricane season cancellation policy.

Top guest favorite

A spacious balcony features several green patio chairs arranged along the wooden floor. The view overlooks the shimmering water, while palm trees sway in the background under a clear blue sky. The balcony is protected by a white railing, enhancing the outdoor space.

Home in Marathon

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews

Paradise Found! Oceanfront home & amazing sunrises

License :VACA-22-182 Escape to our tropical oasis in the Florida Keys! Our vacation house offers a whimsical adventure with fantastic outdoor amenities: balcony, charcoal grill, private pool/spa, hammock, outdoor furniture, and an outdoor freezer for your catch. Stay connected with high-speed internet, enjoy entertainment with a Smart TV and iPhone dock, and rest assured with outdoor security cameras. Book now for an extraordinary getaway!

Guest favorite

A gated entrance is showcased, featuring a white fence and paved driveway leading into the community. Two pastel-colored homes are visible, lined with tropical palm trees. The horizon reveals glimpses of the ocean, creating a serene atmosphere within the community.

Home in Cudjoe Key

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 232 reviews

Newly Renovated Oceanside House with Pool

This home is on the Atlantic side of US 1. It is part of Sunrise Beach Resort, a gated community built in 2007 with only 10 other homes. Lounge in your private hammock or enjoy the gorgeous tropical landscaping and cool breezes on one of two balconies, dock or poolside, where you can soak up the sun steps from the house. Breathtaking southwest views of the blue-green ocean and sunsets can be seen from the pool and dock.

Guest favorite

The exterior of a blue house is surrounded by a landscaped garden featuring palm trees and other greenery. A gravel driveway leads to the entrance, providing ample space for parking. The sky is clear and sunny, enhancing the inviting atmosphere of the property.

Home in Marathon

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Beautiful Renovated Home in Marathon, FL

Cozy home centrally located in the heart of Marathon with a ton of parking space for a boat or RV... Stay at ease in this family friendly neighborhood with lots of fun nearby (within 10 minutes) such as Sombrero Beach, FL Keys Aquarium, public boat ramp, kayaking, diving, restaurants and more!!! Licensed and inspected by the City of Marathon, Lic.#VACA-21-409

Top guest favorite

A private wooden dock extends over calm waters, featuring a boat with a blue canopy and a small table with colorful umbrellas nearby. Palm trees line the waterfront, and a series of pastel-colored homes are visible across the canal, creating a serene setting.

Home in Marathon

5 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Waterfront Oceanside, 60 Ft Dock, As seen on HGTV

See our home on HGTV's "Vacation House for Free", (Rental Lisc#VACA-20-690) BRING YOUR BOAT TO OUR PRIVATE 60 FOOT DOCK WITH 30 AMP SHORE POWER OUTLET. We call our home "Bahama Breeze" because that's what you feel blowing in as you spend your vacation at this Oceanside single family home.